Being a parent and a future educator gives me a unique perspective on censorship; however, simply because I’m a parent does not in any way indicate that I am naïve about the education that children receive outside of a classroom. In fact, my view on censorship is that it is practically laughable. While I can without question agree that children should be protected, I do not agree in banning books in an attempt to uphold that protection. The more censors ban books, the more the books are going to become hot commodities among those the censors swear to protect.
Consider for a moment the following – how often do educators overhear conversations in the hallway of a questionable nature? Should the teacher or administrator be so simple minded as to assume that all of those conversations stemmed from the reading assigned for homework the night before. I highly doubt it. All it takes is one older sibling to inform a younger sibling about the art of profanity and suddenly there is a bus full of kids trying on four letter words for size.
What about the censors themselves? Have they become so high and mighty to forget and consider the times that they were young adults? Did they read something in school that they are now advocating the banning of and nearly vomit at the sight of the words or complain because someone was forcing them to read it? Again, I highly doubt it. They were more than likely lapping it up like kittens with milk, feeling that they were privileged or special for getting to read something so adult in nature.
To ban books is just the beginning of a very slippery downhill slope to a world of education that I do not want to fathom. School classrooms would be allowed to only focus on the books that make it past the censors, school hallways would be void of any conversation, and lunchrooms would be eerily silent because a conversation of any nature has the potential to turn questionable if allowed. If the censors are determined to preserve purity then they are going to have to do a lot more than ban a few books. The world that we live in is not picture perfect, but the books that the censors find issue with are generally the ones who help the struggling adolescent struggle a little less.

Now, I will climb down off of my soap-box and continue with my review of the chapter. I have to admit that throughout this chapter the authors seemed to have the same viewpoint as me. They often mentioned some of the same things that I just previously mentioned about the absurdity of some of the censors rationales. The very last lines of the chapter is one that sums up clearly how the authors feel about censorship, “We believe librarians and English teachers must protect these freedoms [freedom to think and inquire], not merely in abstract, but in the practical, day-by-day world of the school and library. To protect those freedoms, we must fight censorship, for without them no education worthy of the name is possible.” I have to admit, I fully agree with them (in case you didn’t get that sense already).
The chapter does a fantastic job of incorporating landmark court cases, including one from Hawkins County, TN, that changed the face of censorship and varied between giving rights to the censors and giving rights to the teachers/librarians. I thoughrougly enjoyed reading some of the judge’s statements, especially when they hinted it at the nonsense of the censors or school boards. I was particularly grateful for the inclusion of the “What to Do Before and After the Censors Arrive,” section of the chapter. I think that having a well thought out plan before something like this occurs in one’s classroom is imperative. I think the way they broke it down into specific steps is help and beneficial to all of us who are planning on teaching.
I fully agree with one of the statements the authors made in the last part of the text about the fact that generally the naysayer’s just want to be heard, or have a little more explanation. I think this is a very important point for us to remember. Often the ones, who bash things, are the ones who don’t understand them, i.e. the women’s group who could not clearly define secular humanism for the member who asked about. I think by remembering to take time and explain our choices in the classroom will fare much better than arguing back. Case in point, when I was a junior in high school I read A Prayer for Owen Meany. The book was fantastic and a wonderful example of overcoming a disability in childhood and adolescence, and showing a true definition of a hero; but, the book is riddled with profane language and more than likely what some would qualify as lewd imagery and is quite blasphemous at one point in the text – and while yes we all felt special being allowed to read such a thing in school, none of us took advantage of this and treated it like children as most censors assume we would. We looked at the book and explored it for the deeper meaning and the skill of the writing. I would assume that my 11th grade AP English teacher was met with some concerns from parents during the time he taught that book, but I would also venture to guess that he answered those concerns with clear, concise and perfectly acceptable reasoning behind his choice.
Ultimately when considering the chapter on censorship it is important to remember that even though the authors, me, and probably anyone else who reads this chapter feels that censors and censorship is ludicrous, it’s going to occur. People are going to want to continue to shelter their children from the upsets of growing up in this world for as long as they can, and while I fully support that and believe in protecting my children from as much as possible, I cannot stand behind censors and say pulling classics off a shelf is necessary in that protection. In order to have a full and well rounded education students should be exposed to the upsets of the world in a controlled environment that gives them somewhere safe to discuss those things and express their feelings. If I had one word of advice for the parents who are so determined to censor everything except the sunshine and rainbows it’s this – consider how you felt growing up, remember all of the issues you struggled with being called “fat” or “pizza face”. Now that you’ve considered that, pick up the book and read it with your child and then use it as discussion fodder to help your son or daughter through one of the most difficult rites of passage there is – growing up.
Image taken from Blue Heron Blast, which has a list of books that people attempted to ban from 2000-2009